WEBVTT
00:00:01.764 --> 00:00:04.993
It's all of it's been talked about in living rooms across the world.
00:00:04.993 --> 00:00:18.013
Yeah, the Australian mushroom poisoning fatalities made headlines far beyond the sleepy Aussie town in which they happened, and the small amount of information that's been shared with the public proved enough to turn us all into those armchair detectives.
00:00:18.719 --> 00:00:26.013
Welcome to the Mushroom Murder Trial Podcast, an account of a mass killing that has shocked the world.
00:00:26.013 --> 00:00:31.932
I'm Lisa, a journalist who once knew Erin Patterson from a Facebook true crime group.
00:00:31.932 --> 00:00:38.192
Today I will bring you the epic tale known to me as Erin Patterson versus the media.
00:00:38.192 --> 00:00:44.412
It's the story of the chaos from after the deadly lunch to before her arrest.
00:00:44.412 --> 00:00:53.850
From after the deadly lunch to before her arrest, it's August 7, 2023, when Erin answers a knock at her door.
00:00:53.850 --> 00:00:58.981
The 48-year-old, who lives in a semi-rural part of South Gippsland, knows impromptu visits here are rare.
00:00:58.981 --> 00:01:02.649
She's exhausted today and completely overwrought.
00:01:02.649 --> 00:01:11.150
The stakes couldn't be higher because she was a suspect in a fatal food poisoning and her children had been removed from her care.
00:01:11.150 --> 00:01:17.950
Since then, she'd been battling community services for days to have her son and daughter returned to her custody.
00:01:17.950 --> 00:01:26.391
Today she tentatively opens her door and finds the man behind one of the country's most talked about stories.
00:01:27.500 --> 00:01:36.191
John Ferguson, an award-winning reporter for the Australian, is the journalist who first uncovered the tragic Beef, wellington and Mushroom story.
00:01:36.191 --> 00:01:43.789
He is familiar with high-stakes stories and came to Leon Gatha to meet the woman now known as the Mushroom Lady.
00:01:43.789 --> 00:01:46.573
The reception was far from welcoming.
00:01:46.573 --> 00:01:50.469
John told me later that Erin had become defensive.
00:01:50.469 --> 00:01:56.103
She said she was now a wicked witch and launched into a tirade about media ethics.
00:01:56.103 --> 00:02:04.908
This is ironic because Erin used a witch on a broomstick as her profile pic on social media, including Facebook.
00:02:04.908 --> 00:02:10.067
Indeed, every now and then, when I logged onto TikTok, it suggested I follow her.
00:02:10.067 --> 00:02:27.734
So because TikTok is a stalker and likes to find absolutely everyone you know, it realised that Erin and I were linked on Facebook, but from 2019 to 2020, I was in a true crime group with the Mushroom Cook.
00:02:28.240 --> 00:02:33.552
Now I'm doing an entire episode on this, so it will be coming up in later episodes.
00:02:33.552 --> 00:02:43.085
I knew her as someone who was smart, eccentric, funny and longing for connection until she wasn't, but, to be honest, I used to quite like her in the before.
00:02:43.085 --> 00:02:47.697
She was funny until she wasn't, but, to be honest, I used to quite like her in the before she was funny until she wasn't.
00:02:47.697 --> 00:03:02.300
John Ferguson's reception tells you a lot about this mother of two, but, erin, you ain't seen nothing yet, because in a few hours she will be surrounded by more reporters as well as news cameras.
00:03:02.300 --> 00:03:17.890
Erin, returning home from shopping, was recorded, storming around her car, sobbing with no apparent tears and theatrically telling her side of the tragedy scenes that became some of the defining images of the case.
00:03:17.890 --> 00:03:21.056
This is from the Australian's YouTube channel.
00:03:21.701 --> 00:03:23.087
It's a tragedy, what's happened.
00:03:25.461 --> 00:03:26.848
Can you tell us about the meal that you cooked?
00:03:29.780 --> 00:03:43.491
I'm kind of devastated by what's happened, by the loss of Donnie Donnie's still in hospital the loss of Ian and Heather and Gail, who were some of the best people that I've ever met.
00:03:43.491 --> 00:04:03.659
Gail, who was some of the best people that I'd ever met, Gail was like the muff that I didn't have because my mum passed away four years ago and Gail's never been anything but good and kind to me and Anne and Heather were some of the best people I've ever met.
00:04:03.780 --> 00:04:15.329
They never did anything wrong to me and I'm so devastated about what's happened and the loss to the community and to the families and to my own children who've lost their grandmother.
00:04:17.541 --> 00:04:19.067
Can you tell us a bit more about the lunch?
00:04:21.980 --> 00:04:28.014
What I can tell you is that I just can't fathom what has happened.
00:04:28.014 --> 00:04:38.785
I just can't fathom what has happened that Ian and Emma have lost their lives and Gail has lost her life and Dawn is still in hospital and I pray.
00:04:38.785 --> 00:04:44.348
I pray that he pulls through, because my children love him.
00:04:45.901 --> 00:04:47.608
And you must be pretty shaken up by this as well.
00:04:48.860 --> 00:04:49.785
I'm devastated.
00:04:49.785 --> 00:04:57.430
I love them and I can't believe that this has happened, and I'm so sorry that they have lost their lives.
00:04:58.281 --> 00:05:05.872
Under the relentless stress of the police and the media spotlight, she was determined to grasp control in her own mercurial way.
00:05:05.872 --> 00:05:11.509
The situation then escalates into a shite, as we say.
00:05:11.509 --> 00:05:22.684
Erin, looking up to the sky as though she hoped it would swallow her up, wipes away invisible tears and then checks her fingers for those pretend tears.
00:05:22.684 --> 00:05:29.586
These unforgettable viral moments offered the world glimpses into Erin's unpredictable character.
00:05:29.586 --> 00:05:39.396
As the media set up camp across the road from her home, erin continues with her sporadic and increasingly bizarre interventions.
00:05:39.396 --> 00:05:44.689
Her dishevelled appearance, quaint choice of words I cannot fathom.
00:05:44.689 --> 00:05:46.880
I cannot fathom Now.
00:05:46.880 --> 00:05:51.471
As someone who used to be a media trainer, that's not a natural thing to say.
00:05:51.471 --> 00:05:57.213
I think she'd been practising in her head what she would say if she was approached by media.
00:05:57.213 --> 00:06:03.432
But I think the panic, the lack of experience, just ended up being a disaster.
00:06:03.432 --> 00:06:06.610
Erin is screwing up her cover-up.
00:06:06.872 --> 00:06:13.850
Chris Watts is another family murderer whose TV interviews put a flashing guilty sign above his head.
00:06:13.850 --> 00:06:20.089
On camera he was giggling, licking his lips and talking about his victims in the past tense.
00:06:20.089 --> 00:06:22.819
Here's a portion of one of his interviews.
00:06:22.819 --> 00:06:47.656
He thought he'd get away with killing his family because he didn't care about them.
00:06:47.656 --> 00:06:57.896
Therefore, he thought no one would notice if they went missing, but what seems to be of low intelligence, whereas Aaron is likely at genius level.
00:06:57.896 --> 00:06:59.680
Not that I'm a psychologist.
00:06:59.680 --> 00:07:06.497
What they both got wrong was the massive impact their murders would have on their families and local communities.
00:07:06.497 --> 00:07:10.095
Their victims meant nothing to them, but they were cherished.
00:07:10.095 --> 00:07:19.156
With that love comes the police, scrutiny and the media, which loves telling stories of mystery, light and shade.
00:07:19.156 --> 00:07:22.694
I don't blame the media for Erin's outbursts.
00:07:22.694 --> 00:07:29.749
She was just giving them her best version of Shakespeare's Lady Macbeth Out down spot Out, down spot.
00:07:31.233 --> 00:07:37.057
Out, I say the media was finding Erin's emotional outbursts captivating.
00:07:37.057 --> 00:07:43.298
Indeed, some of YouTube's biggest news channels were soon following the story.
00:07:43.298 --> 00:07:46.774
Her theatrics were born for an online world.
00:07:46.774 --> 00:07:52.788
To say that interest was high is an absurd understatement.
00:07:52.788 --> 00:08:00.629
After the arrest, victorian homicide boss Detective Inspector Dean Thomas was urging everyone to calm down.
00:08:00.629 --> 00:08:06.788
This is what he said and it was used in a previous episode of this podcast.
00:08:07.391 --> 00:08:13.468
Over the last three months, this investigation has been subject to incredibly intense levels of public scrutiny and curiosity.
00:08:13.468 --> 00:08:23.007
I cannot think of another investigation that has generated this level of media and public interest, not only here in Victoria, but also nationally and internationally.
00:08:23.007 --> 00:08:29.053
I think it's particularly important that we keep in mind that, at the heart of this, three people have lost their lives.
00:08:29.053 --> 00:08:35.378
These are three people who, by all accounts, were much beloved in their communities and are greatly missed by their loved ones.
00:08:35.378 --> 00:08:46.394
These deaths also continue to have a significant impact on the media, on the immediate families of those involved, and I ask that people are particularly mindful of this over the coming days.
00:08:47.136 --> 00:08:49.562
And I ask that people are particularly mindful of this over the coming days.
00:08:49.562 --> 00:09:00.879
Meanwhile, back in time to August 2023, erin is retreating inside her Gibson Street home, the same house where she fantasised, planned and executed her homicides, or attempted to.
00:09:00.879 --> 00:09:09.306
Can you see her farewelling her in-laws, gathering up their deadly plates and washing them as though everything was normal?
00:09:09.306 --> 00:09:16.649
Despite Erin's attempt to control the media, her efforts continue to backfire and are making things worse.
00:09:16.649 --> 00:09:28.239
Her words were riddled with contradictions and denials, including the infamous remark where she mistakenly declared one of the victims survivor, ian Wilkinson, dead.
00:09:28.239 --> 00:09:33.611
The mum of two didn't look like a multimillionaire, as the media were describing her.
00:09:33.611 --> 00:09:35.451
But who does when you're at home?
00:09:35.451 --> 00:09:43.897
As the days went on, erin's interactions with reporters drew more scrutiny as her world spiralled out of control.
00:09:43.897 --> 00:09:47.514
Despite her attempts to control the media narrative.
00:09:47.514 --> 00:09:50.647
The efforts made everything worse.
00:09:50.647 --> 00:09:58.288
Now I've got to tell everyone here lawyers always say to you do not speak to the media in this kind of situation.
00:09:58.288 --> 00:10:07.735
But the point that Erin's at now, something needs to happen and lawyers are risk adverse and they can't control the media.
00:10:07.735 --> 00:10:12.327
But she's certainly making it difficult for herself.
00:10:12.327 --> 00:10:18.028
But she was told not to speak to the media even though she has, so it's a hard one to think about.
00:10:18.028 --> 00:10:23.527
The second time she addressed reporters, Erin was again messy in appearance.
00:10:23.527 --> 00:10:29.467
But looking good is probably not a priority when you're at the centre of a deadly food investigation.
00:10:29.467 --> 00:10:35.769
Having known Erin, it's my opinion that her children are the only things she truly cares about.
00:10:35.769 --> 00:10:41.826
The fact that they had been taken from her just days before looms large in her mind.
00:10:41.826 --> 00:10:47.739
As she spoke to reporters she was very distressed that her children had been removed from her.
00:10:48.384 --> 00:10:56.293
Meanwhile, the mushroom cook's chaotic interactions with reporters drew more scrutiny as her world spiralled out of control.
00:10:56.293 --> 00:11:08.653
When Erin left her Leon Gather home on August 8, taking a bulky suitcase, it was suggested the luggage was for the kids' clothing there was confusion too across Australia.
00:11:08.653 --> 00:11:11.249
Surely all of this is an accident.
00:11:11.249 --> 00:11:13.953
It's too bizarre to be deliberate.
00:11:13.953 --> 00:11:22.197
But if Erin had stayed inside or left town after the Australian first turned up, she might have avoided such a spectacle.
00:11:22.197 --> 00:11:24.489
But there's no room for sympathy.
00:11:25.389 --> 00:11:31.929
As an extreme introvert, erin didn't have anyone close by who could help her with everyday essentials.
00:11:31.929 --> 00:11:34.817
She was leaning heavily upon members of our group.
00:11:34.817 --> 00:11:44.467
I believe the carport statements she made were indicative of her ability to create drama wherever she went.
00:11:44.467 --> 00:11:50.979
Erin should have shut her door, streamed several of her shows and held tight.
00:11:50.979 --> 00:11:57.258
The second time she addressed reporters, she was in a red sweater and beige pants.
00:11:57.258 --> 00:12:03.937
There's footage of her also yelling from her front door wearing a blue sweater and beige pants.
00:12:03.937 --> 00:12:07.654
It's very hard to line all this up, but I'm doing my best.
00:12:07.654 --> 00:12:11.433
It's crazy For someone who wanted to avoid journalists.
00:12:11.453 --> 00:12:20.317
She was spending August battling interview requests at her semi-rural home, the one where she murdered three people, according to the age.
00:12:20.317 --> 00:12:26.278
She complained she wasn't able to leave her house to feed her sheep or go to the supermarket.
00:12:26.278 --> 00:12:33.073
From the start, the main Patterson and Wilkinson families had a public relations representative working for them.
00:12:33.073 --> 00:12:40.798
This was smart because they had media knocking on their windows, leaving notes in their letterbox and ringing their doorbells.
00:12:40.798 --> 00:12:41.787
For days.
00:12:41.787 --> 00:12:45.774
Erin's property allowed for her to have much more privacy.
00:12:45.774 --> 00:12:51.091
She had to learn not to react, but now it doesn't matter.
00:12:51.091 --> 00:12:58.068
What she didn't realise was the journalists had every right to ask questions, but she had every right not to answer them.
00:12:59.350 --> 00:13:04.403
This heated exchange coming up was distributed on screens worldwide.
00:13:04.403 --> 00:13:16.761
In Leon Gatha, the media wasn't backing down and Erin reasonably felt trapped, but every now and then she throws us a curveball and we find out who she really is.
00:13:16.761 --> 00:13:26.991
She'd locked reporters inside her property in a probable attempt to exert some sense of control over a situation that was spiralling.
00:13:26.991 --> 00:13:36.379
Following the homicide squad's declaration of her as a suspect, everything is going off the rails when it comes to Erin.
00:13:36.379 --> 00:13:39.191
Didn't she want the media to leave, then?
00:13:39.191 --> 00:13:41.196
Why lock the reporters in?
00:13:41.196 --> 00:13:43.301
That's absolutely creepy.
00:13:44.443 --> 00:13:52.971
Erin, again, was completely self-centred and bothered by the perceived inconvenience brought about by the deaths and the resultant media coverage.
00:13:52.971 --> 00:13:58.423
Here she reminds me of a character from Stephen King's Misery series.
00:13:58.423 --> 00:14:04.663
Annie Wilkes is a cunning, brutal and devious woman who, like Erin, hides her malice.
00:14:04.663 --> 00:14:08.961
Both the novel and the film portray her as paranoid.
00:14:08.961 --> 00:14:14.796
Plus, she has an unhealthy obsession with romance novels Coming up too.
00:14:14.796 --> 00:14:22.917
In my episode about the group, we'll find out what type of non-fiction material Erin Patterson read.
00:14:22.917 --> 00:14:27.393
By the way, erin looks a lot like the actress who played Annie Wilkes.
00:14:27.393 --> 00:14:30.277
It was Kathy Bates.
00:14:31.538 --> 00:14:33.743
You dirty bird.
00:14:33.743 --> 00:14:35.085
How could?
00:14:35.085 --> 00:14:38.234
You were good, paul, but you're not good.
00:14:38.234 --> 00:14:41.379
You're just another lying old dirty birdie.
00:14:41.999 --> 00:14:42.880
Back to August.
00:14:42.880 --> 00:14:50.701
Erin comes out her front door, gets into her car and drives to the gate where she has a discussion with a TV journalist.
00:14:50.701 --> 00:14:54.480
She was asked if she had any support within the community.
00:14:54.480 --> 00:15:00.418
I've got tons of friends who've offered me help, but I've told them to stay away while the vultures are here.
00:15:00.418 --> 00:15:08.096
From what I know, that was going on in Erin's inner sanctum by August the 10th.
00:15:08.096 --> 00:15:11.263
There are a lot of people who are just taking notes and listening.
00:15:11.263 --> 00:15:21.636
There are a few people who strongly believe she was innocent and this was a terrible, terrible mix-up while there were others who were feeling suspicious.
00:15:21.636 --> 00:15:28.875
Erin then drove through the gate of the rural property and left off to Melbourne to see a lawyer.
00:15:28.875 --> 00:15:33.679
Apparently, the news of her visit to the barrister quickly spread.
00:15:33.679 --> 00:15:36.519
Then someone leaked her police statement.
00:15:36.519 --> 00:15:40.716
There's one way to fix that Don't engage in mass murder.
00:15:41.410 --> 00:15:44.681
Because when her scheme collapsed, the fallout was swift and intense.
00:15:44.681 --> 00:16:01.389
First the police named her as a suspect and there was blowback, partly due to a statement filled with lies issued by someone who had a relationship to this story and the case and the investigation.
00:16:01.389 --> 00:16:11.283
It read in part I now very much regret not answering some questions following the advice, given the nightmare that this process has become.
00:16:11.283 --> 00:16:17.245
Erin stated that she found the police interview terrifying and anxiety provoking.
00:16:17.245 --> 00:16:21.400
The mushrooms she used to cook the beef wellington were bought from a local supermarket.
00:16:21.400 --> 00:16:23.347
She said, as well as other dried mushrooms she'd bought from a local supermarket.
00:16:23.347 --> 00:16:27.220
She said as well as other dried mushrooms she'd bought from an Asian grocery store.
00:16:27.220 --> 00:16:38.572
She stated she too consumed the mushroom meal and was hospitalised at Melbourne Monash Medical Centre as she had stomach pains and terrible diarrhoea.
00:16:38.572 --> 00:16:43.421
I was put on a saline drip and stayed in hospital overnight.
00:16:43.421 --> 00:16:45.445
I was given some medicine.
00:16:45.445 --> 00:16:48.755
I was told it was a liver protective drug.
00:16:48.755 --> 00:16:49.878
Her statement read.
00:16:49.878 --> 00:16:53.533
I'm hoping this statement might help in some way.
00:16:53.533 --> 00:16:59.832
I believe if people understood the background more they would not be so quick to rush to judgment.
00:16:59.832 --> 00:17:04.363
By the end of August she'd encountered the media at least six times.
00:17:05.230 --> 00:17:12.423
Meanwhile, back in Facebook land, I was suspected for leaking Erin's screenshots to the Daily Mail.
00:17:12.423 --> 00:17:22.160
It wasn't me, because I didn't know Erin on an intimate level and these contained some very personal information about her childhood and family.
00:17:22.160 --> 00:17:28.780
I had, however, spoken with John Ferguson and Brooke Grebbit Craig from the Herald Sun.
00:17:28.780 --> 00:17:35.538
This was after I'd asked him on my podcast and I told Brooke what I knew about Erin's online.
00:17:35.538 --> 00:17:50.656
I didn't, however, speak with any police officers, but on August 29, 2023, one month after the fatal lunch, our mushroom cook was strutting through the Melbourne CBD with the media in tow.
00:17:50.656 --> 00:17:52.460
This is exhausting.
00:17:52.460 --> 00:17:59.098
Even talking about it, my goodness, it was again a peculiar sight.
00:17:59.098 --> 00:18:08.336
An ashen-faced Erin, dressed in grey animal jumper and khaki pants, declined to speak as she was followed by the media to a parked car.
00:18:08.336 --> 00:18:17.800
Now, before anyone complains about me describing outfits, this thing's so chaotic it's the only way I can make sense of it.
00:18:17.800 --> 00:18:19.203
Which was what day?
00:18:19.203 --> 00:18:20.172
What did she say?
00:18:20.172 --> 00:18:24.663
It's just a good kind of if you're someone who reacts well to colour.
00:18:24.663 --> 00:18:26.251
That's what I'm doing.
00:18:26.251 --> 00:18:39.673
According to the Daily Mail, it was unclear how some reporters were alerted to the meeting with her lawyers who, quote, have previously been suspected of leaking their client's police statement to select journalists.
00:18:39.673 --> 00:18:48.375
Ie the ABC Note, this legal team was not the pair who represented her in the Supreme Court of Victoria.
00:18:48.375 --> 00:18:53.330
Speaking to the Australian afterwards, erin denied she'd leaked the statement.
00:18:53.853 --> 00:18:58.663
Ultimately, erin's efforts to manage the crisis spiralled out of control.
00:18:58.663 --> 00:19:09.678
The media frenzy, her responses and her self-destructive handling of this bizarre situation became features of this tragic saga.
00:19:09.678 --> 00:19:11.040
Her blind panic.
00:19:11.040 --> 00:19:20.692
Now I can understand that it is a very difficult situation to be, but that blind panic took over and made things worse as she spiralled.
00:19:20.692 --> 00:19:26.971
This is what she should have done no media, but no, she couldn't help herself.
00:19:26.971 --> 00:19:32.632
But despite these efforts, she kept making a complete mess of her non-verbal communication.
00:19:32.632 --> 00:19:38.423
Her blind panic took over, only making things worse in front of the journalists.
00:19:39.529 --> 00:19:57.287
But one thing she'd be pleased about was to know that the prosecutors were, from the start of this pretrial process, closely monitored by the Department of Public Prosecutions to prevent any risk of mistrial due to potential jury contamination.
00:19:57.287 --> 00:20:07.195
Technically go to jail for this it's known as contempt of court.
00:20:07.195 --> 00:20:15.141
It's normal for any trial in Australia to be extremely careful during the pre-trial process, but this time there were many warnings straight from the Supreme Court of Victoria.
00:20:15.141 --> 00:20:22.296
This level of oversight created significant pressure and anxiety because no one wanted to stuff this up.
00:20:22.296 --> 00:20:29.665
So thank you so much for listening today to Erin Patterson versus the media.
00:20:29.665 --> 00:20:34.320
My name is Lisa and you can contact me on my socials.
00:20:34.320 --> 00:20:42.002
They're in the show notes and on top of that I'll be bringing out more episodes that I've been putting together.
00:20:42.002 --> 00:20:47.996
And thank you again so much and I will speak to you very, very soon.
00:20:47.996 --> 00:20:48.897
Bye.