May 11, 2025
Inside the Mushroom Murder Trial: A Son's Perspective on Deadly Lunch
The player is loading ...
The jury in the Mushroom Murder Trial was given a day off to handle administrative matters, while tomorrow's hearings will proceed as scheduled in the Supreme Court of Victoria in Morwell.
Today's episode focuses on the son's statement to police about his mother Erin Patterson, who stands accused, but denies, serving a deadly mushroom dish to family members during a lunch at her home.
• Erin Patterson faces three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder for allegedly serving death cap mushrooms to her former in-laws
• Her son described his parents' relationship as "very negative" with his father doing "things to try and hurt mum"
• The son wasn't present at the mushroom lunch but returned home while guests were still there and helped clean up afterwards
• He ate leftovers from the lunch the next day, describing the beef Wellington as "some of the best meat I've ever had" without becoming ill
• Erin Patterson became sick with diarrhoea and dizziness the day after the mushroom lunch
• The son and his sibling were taken to hospital for tests but were cleared and allowed to go home
• Erin Patterson appeared emotional in court while watching her son's video testimony, nodding and smiling at certain points.
Visit mushroommurdertrialcom for updates and information about the trial. Follow the podcast on Instagram, YouTube , Facebook , Blue Sky, and Twitter. Support the production through Buy Me A Coffee membership for exclusive content – just $5 helps cover editing, studio hire, liability insurance, equipment, and production costs for The Mushroom Murder Trial Podcast.
Instagram @Erin_Podcast
Twitter @lisapodcasts
Mushroom Murder Trial
Website
.
Erin Patterson Mushrooms
Here it is in summary.
WEBVTT
00:00:00.700 --> 00:00:09.444
Hello and welcome to the Mushroom Murder Trial podcast, your go-to source for detailed updates on this gripping legal case.
00:00:09.444 --> 00:00:15.762
I'm Lisa, your host and podcaster, who's been tracking this case since 2023.
00:00:15.762 --> 00:00:24.934
The jury was given a day off today, monday, so the court could deal with a few administrative issues relating to the trial.
00:00:24.934 --> 00:00:36.524
Tomorrow, hearings will proceed as scheduled in the Supreme Court of Melbourne Sorry, I should say the Supreme Court of Victoria in Morwell.
00:00:36.524 --> 00:00:47.908
But before we dive into the rest of our news, don't forget to sign up for the newsletter mushroommurdertrialcom, and make sure you subscribe to this podcast, please.
00:00:47.908 --> 00:00:49.847
That way you won't miss a thing.
00:00:49.847 --> 00:00:54.792
Now to the formalities, before we move on to what unfolded in court.
00:00:54.792 --> 00:01:00.929
Now you may wonder why I actually do these, and it's just because it's a defamation risk.
00:01:00.929 --> 00:01:11.647
There could be another Erin Patter, who's 50 in Victoria, and they could actually say we were reporting on them when we're not.
00:01:11.647 --> 00:01:13.710
So I just need to be careful.
00:01:14.393 --> 00:01:23.768
Erin Trudy Patterson, a 50-year-old woman from Leangatha, is facing, but denies three counts of murder and one count of attempted murder.
00:01:23.768 --> 00:01:40.328
She stands accused of intentionally serving a dish made with death cap mushrooms to her former in-laws and extended family during a lunch at her home on July 29, 2023, an allegation which she denies.
00:01:40.328 --> 00:01:51.947
Following their tragic family lunch, don and Gail Patterson, both aged 70, along with Gail's sister, 66-year-old Heather Wilkinson, passed away.
00:01:51.947 --> 00:02:00.046
Ian Wilkinson, heather's husband, was also hospitalised in a critical condition but managed to survive.
00:02:00.046 --> 00:02:09.481
Last week, the jury saw video from August 16, 2023 of Erin's two children giving statements to police.
00:02:09.481 --> 00:02:13.252
Today we're going to run through the son's statement.
00:02:13.252 --> 00:02:19.591
When asked about his parents' relationship, he described it as quote very negative.
00:02:19.591 --> 00:02:25.004
The son said Erin and Simon Patterson quote had a few arguments.
00:02:25.004 --> 00:02:32.308
Quote I know dad does a lot of things to try and hurt mum, such as messing around with the school, he said.
00:02:32.308 --> 00:02:33.733
In his interview.
00:02:34.400 --> 00:02:42.045
Miss Patterson's son stated he hadn't attended the lunch but was instead watching the movie Elemental in nearby Corrumburra.
00:02:42.045 --> 00:02:45.995
If you hear that noise, that's my cat, sorry.
00:02:45.995 --> 00:02:54.433
He said he arrived home at about 3pm and then chatted with his grandfather, don, about his hobby flight training.
00:02:54.433 --> 00:03:01.116
He said he'd gotten back home about half an hour before Don, gail, ian and Heather left the house.
00:03:01.116 --> 00:03:05.711
The son observed the group sitting around the dining table and chatting.
00:03:05.711 --> 00:03:13.493
He recalled them as being in good spirits and once again spoke with Don about the flying lessons.
00:03:13.493 --> 00:03:17.711
After the guests had left, he said he helped his mother clean up the house.
00:03:18.240 --> 00:03:18.600
Quote.
00:03:18.600 --> 00:03:23.412
I remember taking some plates up to the sink and putting them in the dishwasher.
00:03:23.412 --> 00:03:27.751
He said I collected the plates, put them in a pile next to the sink.
00:03:27.751 --> 00:03:31.306
I collected all the glasses, put them near the sink.
00:03:31.306 --> 00:03:41.561
He noted that there didn't seem to be any leftover food on the dishes, describing the plates as quote plain white and about 15 centimetres across.
00:03:41.561 --> 00:03:45.328
When asked further, he confirmed they all looked the same.
00:03:45.328 --> 00:03:49.342
The son then spent time playing video games with a friend.
00:03:49.342 --> 00:03:56.768
Later that evening he went upstairs to ask his mother for a ride home for his friend and found her quote building Lego.
00:03:57.430 --> 00:04:01.942
The following morning he saw his mother seated at the dining table with a cup of coffee.
00:04:01.942 --> 00:04:06.889
Mum said she was feeling a bit sick and had diarrhoea.
00:04:06.889 --> 00:04:10.395
She said she woke up a few times through the night to go to the toilet.
00:04:10.395 --> 00:04:12.925
He recalled she wasn't feeling well.
00:04:12.925 --> 00:04:14.438
She said she was feeling dizzy.
00:04:14.438 --> 00:04:22.574
He observed that she was more subdued than usual and suspected she might have been downplaying how unwell she was.
00:04:23.360 --> 00:04:32.754
They skipped church that day as Erin did not want to risk infecting others, but she still encouraged him to attend his flight lesson.
00:04:32.754 --> 00:04:33.641
Quote.
00:04:33.641 --> 00:04:39.774
Around 11.30am I came out to mum to ask if she's still okay for the flying lesson.
00:04:39.774 --> 00:04:43.122
Just assure her if it was okay.
00:04:43.122 --> 00:04:47.488
If we didn't go they set off for Tyab Tyab.
00:04:47.488 --> 00:04:56.728
Sorry that afternoon but the lesson ended up being cancelled due to poor weather at the last minute.
00:04:56.728 --> 00:05:02.423
They didn't make any bathroom stops along the way.
00:05:02.423 --> 00:05:06.129
But returning home, ms Patterson quickly headed inside.
00:05:06.129 --> 00:05:10.345
She raced to the front door and said I need to go to the toilet.
00:05:10.345 --> 00:05:12.173
He recounted that evening.
00:05:12.173 --> 00:05:16.305
She told her children they'd be having the leftovers from the previous day's lunch.
00:05:16.305 --> 00:05:20.581
He remembered the meal beef, mashed potatoes and green beans.
00:05:20.581 --> 00:05:25.809
It was very soft and was probably some of the best meat I've ever had.
00:05:25.809 --> 00:05:29.415
He said I cut it up into cubes and I ate it.
00:05:30.581 --> 00:05:35.132
On Monday their father took the children to Monash Children's Hospital in Melbourne.
00:05:35.132 --> 00:05:46.447
The son said his mother was in hospital and he underwent three blood tests between Monday and Tuesday but was later cleared and allowed to go home.
00:05:46.447 --> 00:05:49.244
The son said he hadn't felt sick at any point.
00:05:49.244 --> 00:05:51.312
In the end it was nothing, he said.
00:05:51.312 --> 00:06:00.677
Then we just stayed with mum and we went back to school on Monday because Erin was in the same hospital by Thursday.
00:06:00.677 --> 00:06:06.649
His mother was still unwell, continuing to drink coffee and reporting dizziness and a clammy feeling.
00:06:06.649 --> 00:06:09.334
She said she was feeling clammy and dizzy.
00:06:09.334 --> 00:06:15.451
He said Ms Patterson watched her son's statement from the courtroom via a video feed.
00:06:15.451 --> 00:06:20.050
She appeared emotional at certain points and wiped her face with a tissue.
00:06:20.050 --> 00:06:25.411
She nodded when he spoke and smiled when he mentioned her love of cooking.
00:06:25.411 --> 00:06:27.444
She likes cooking brownies.
00:06:27.444 --> 00:06:28.708
She loves her roasts.
00:06:28.708 --> 00:06:33.853
He said Thanks for listening to the Mushroom Murder Trial podcast today.
00:06:34.295 --> 00:06:36.822
Make sure you subscribe so you get the latest.
00:06:36.822 --> 00:06:41.192
For more information, go to the website mushroommurdertrialcom.
00:06:41.192 --> 00:06:44.105
It's jam-packed with news about the trial.
00:06:44.105 --> 00:06:45.910
Plus, I'm on Instagram.
00:06:45.910 --> 00:06:50.846
You can find me on Facebook, youtube X I don't know I'm on all of them.
00:06:50.846 --> 00:06:53.194
I'll put links in the show notes.
00:06:53.194 --> 00:07:09.992
And if you're feeling like rewarding me for the thousands of hours I've spent on this work, I have a Buy Me A Coffee membership which allows you to pay one off, $5 as a thanks and I get coffee or gin, depending on how my day goes.
00:07:09.992 --> 00:07:17.252
This ensures I can afford the editing studio, hire, liability insurance, equipment, sound and voiceovers.
00:07:17.252 --> 00:07:22.791
Plus, you will get exclusive membership material on the site just for you.
00:07:22.791 --> 00:07:24.583
So have a great day, everyone.
00:07:24.583 --> 00:07:25.884
I will speak to you soon.
00:07:25.884 --> 00:07:26.687
Thank you, bye.
00:00:00.700 --> 00:00:09.444
00:00:09.444 --> 00:00:15.762
00:00:15.762 --> 00:00:24.934
00:00:24.934 --> 00:00:36.524
00:00:36.524 --> 00:00:47.908
00:00:47.908 --> 00:00:49.847
00:00:49.847 --> 00:00:54.792
00:00:54.792 --> 00:01:00.929
00:01:00.929 --> 00:01:11.647
00:01:11.647 --> 00:01:13.710
00:01:14.393 --> 00:01:23.768
00:01:23.768 --> 00:01:40.328
00:01:40.328 --> 00:01:51.947
00:01:51.947 --> 00:02:00.046
00:02:00.046 --> 00:02:09.481
00:02:09.481 --> 00:02:13.252
00:02:13.252 --> 00:02:19.591
00:02:19.591 --> 00:02:25.004
00:02:25.004 --> 00:02:32.308
00:02:32.308 --> 00:02:33.733
00:02:34.400 --> 00:02:42.045
00:02:42.045 --> 00:02:45.995
00:02:45.995 --> 00:02:54.433
00:02:54.433 --> 00:03:01.116
00:03:01.116 --> 00:03:05.711
00:03:05.711 --> 00:03:13.493
00:03:13.493 --> 00:03:17.711
00:03:18.240 --> 00:03:18.600
00:03:18.600 --> 00:03:23.412
00:03:23.412 --> 00:03:27.751
00:03:27.751 --> 00:03:31.306
00:03:31.306 --> 00:03:41.561
00:03:41.561 --> 00:03:45.328
00:03:45.328 --> 00:03:49.342
00:03:49.342 --> 00:03:56.768
00:03:57.430 --> 00:04:01.942
00:04:01.942 --> 00:04:06.889
00:04:06.889 --> 00:04:10.395
00:04:10.395 --> 00:04:12.925
00:04:12.925 --> 00:04:14.438
00:04:14.438 --> 00:04:22.574
00:04:23.360 --> 00:04:32.754
00:04:32.754 --> 00:04:33.641
00:04:33.641 --> 00:04:39.774
00:04:39.774 --> 00:04:43.122
00:04:43.122 --> 00:04:47.488
00:04:47.488 --> 00:04:56.728
00:04:56.728 --> 00:05:02.423
00:05:02.423 --> 00:05:06.129
00:05:06.129 --> 00:05:10.345
00:05:10.345 --> 00:05:12.173
00:05:12.173 --> 00:05:16.305
00:05:16.305 --> 00:05:20.581
00:05:20.581 --> 00:05:25.809
00:05:25.809 --> 00:05:29.415
00:05:30.581 --> 00:05:35.132
00:05:35.132 --> 00:05:46.447
00:05:46.447 --> 00:05:49.244
00:05:49.244 --> 00:05:51.312
00:05:51.312 --> 00:06:00.677
00:06:00.677 --> 00:06:06.649
00:06:06.649 --> 00:06:09.334
00:06:09.334 --> 00:06:15.451
00:06:15.451 --> 00:06:20.050
00:06:20.050 --> 00:06:25.411
00:06:25.411 --> 00:06:27.444
00:06:27.444 --> 00:06:28.708
00:06:28.708 --> 00:06:33.853
00:06:34.295 --> 00:06:36.822
00:06:36.822 --> 00:06:41.192
00:06:41.192 --> 00:06:44.105
00:06:44.105 --> 00:06:45.910
00:06:45.910 --> 00:06:50.846
00:06:50.846 --> 00:06:53.194
00:06:53.194 --> 00:07:09.992
00:07:09.992 --> 00:07:17.252
00:07:17.252 --> 00:07:22.791
00:07:22.791 --> 00:07:24.583
00:07:24.583 --> 00:07:25.884
00:07:25.884 --> 00:07:26.687
